EXH AR024619: Draft Memo Range-Finding Water-Effect Ratios Miller & Des Moines Creeks

A February 2000 draft memorandum from Parametrix, Inc. outlines a scope and budget for range-finding Water-Effect Ratio (WER) studies using receiving water from Miller and Des Moines Creeks, intended to help determine whether copper discharge standards at a Port facility could be adjusted through site-specific water quality criteria. The studies involve acute toxicity tests comparing copper-spiked site water to copper-spiked laboratory water, with estimated costs ranging from $2,110 for one site to $2,650 for two sites. Results from earlier 1999 range-finding tests suggested WERs high enough to potentially justify more definitive studies, but new tests without mixing zone assumptions were recommended to better assess achievable permit limits.

Notes

Draft memorandum (AR024619–AR024621) from Doug Henderson and Linda Logan of Parametrix, Inc. to Keith Smith, dated February 28, 2000, providing scope and budget for range-finding Water-Effect Ratios (WERs) using receiving water from Miller Creek and Des Moines Creek. Study necessitated in the event Port Of Seattle is not granted a mixing zone. Describes WER methodology using concurrent acute toxicity tests with copper-spiked site water and copper-spiked laboratory water, median lethal concentration (LC50) calculations, and application of WER to generic water quality standards (WQS) to derive site-specific standards. References February 23, 1999 range-finding results showing copper WERs of approximately 16, 7, and 15 for Miller, Walker, and Des Moines Creeks respectively under SDS3 stormwater mixing zone assumptions. Recommends definitive acute Ceriodaphnia dubia tests; cost table estimates $1,570 per test set, $2,110 for one site, $2,650 for two sites. Discusses dissolved oxygen monitoring equipment constraints for Walker Creek sampling. Project number 556-2912-001.

V V