EXH AR023557: Water Resources Consulting to Ecology — Des Moines Creek Flow Augmentation Facility

A September 26, 2000 letter from Water Resources Consulting L.L.C. to the Washington State Department of Ecology critiques the Port of Seattle's plans to augment water flow in Des Moines Creek, a project related to Sea-Tac Airport operations. The letter identifies several serious flaws in the proposal, including the lack of a secured water source, concerns about water temperature and fluoride toxicity to fish, and a maintenance-intensive design prone to failure. The author concludes that the Port's 'preliminary design' does not provide reasonable assurance that water quality standards will be met.

Notes

Letter dated September 26, 2000 from Peter Willing, Ph.D. of Water Resources Consulting L.L.C. (Bellingham, WA) to Ray Hellwig, Regional Director, Northwest Regional Office, Washington State Department of Ecology, transmitted by fax. Comments on the Kennedy/Jenks Consultants preliminary design for the Des Moines Creek Flow Augmentation Facility prepared for the Port Of Seattle, September 2000. Identifies deficiencies including: no secured water source, unsuitable temperature of Seattle Public Utilities (SPU) water from existing water main at south end of runway 34R, failure to address fluoride toxicity to fish and biota (citing Dr. John Strand letter of August 21, 2000), hygroscopic sodium sulfate maintenance issues, missing chemical reaction for chlorine removal compound, inadequate dechlorination experience, and reliance on a downstream weir prone to fouling. References Implementation Plan July 25, 2000; Revised Implementation Plan August 18, 2000; Flow Augmentation Update email Keith Smith to Tom Luster September 6, 2000. AR 023557–023558.

V V