EXH 370: Letter Columbia Biological Assessments to WDFW Reviewing JARPA Miller Creek Project

A fisheries biologist hired by the Airport Communities Coalition reviewed the Port of Seattle's permit application for the Miller Creek Relocation Project, raising serious scientific concerns about the proposed construction near Sea-Tac Airport. The review found that the project design lacked supporting scientific citations and calculations, and concluded that summer water temperatures would likely exceed safe levels for cutthroat trout for several years until riparian vegetation matured. Additional concerns were raised about inadequate water flow depths and the risk of the stream running dry due to highly porous spawning gravels used in the channel design.

Notes

Letter dated December 8, 2000 from J. Strand of Columbia Biological Assessments, Richland, Washington, to Phillip Schneider of the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife, reviewing the Joint Aquatic Resources Permit Application (JARPA) for the Miller Creek Project prepared by Parametrix, Inc. for the Port Of Seattle. Commissioned by the Airport Communities Coalition (ACC). Exhibit AR021351. The letter critiques the scientific adequacy of the 980-foot Miller Creek Relocation Project and four instream enhancement projects, identifying deficiencies in the Natural Resource Mitigation Plan (NRMP): lack of scientific citations for cutthroat trout habitat design standards, failure to provide hydraulic calculations supporting the 0.25-foot minimum flow depth at 0.5-cfs summer low flow, and risks of the stream going dry due to high-porosity spawning gravels overlaying geotextile fabric. References analysis by William Rozeboom of Northwest Hydraulic Consultants finding actual flow depth of approximately 0.15 feet (not 0.25 feet) and riffle depth of 0.06 feet. Raises concerns about summer water temperature exceedances, depressed oxygen concentrations, fish stranding, and bank erosion following removal of tire riprap without adequate riparian vegetation for stabilization.

V V