EXH0405021838

PCHBPollution Control Hearings Board of the State of Washington

. - m,. _1| I |l II IIII |J IJ _ - III II II • 6August200i U.$. Army Corp_of Engineers RegulatoryBnmch P,O. Box 3755 $¢s_Je,,WA 98124 ATTN: Muff-yWalkodGailTcr_ WashingtonState D=partmentof F_ology 8horelandsandEnvironmcn_Assistanccl_ugram ,3190-160thAve.SE Bell_vu©,WA 9g008 ATI'N: Ann Kormy.Envimnm_ Specialist Subject: CommentsonRecentlyl_ccivcd Do_unent_P_rlainingto ScattleTacomaInternationalAkpor¢I_jcct Thkd Runway- EmbankmentFill andW_'_MSE Wall OeoSyntcc Consu|t_s (GcoSyatec)has bccfl lcCsixcdon behalf of the Airport CommunitiesCoalidon to l=ovid¢a technicalreviewof inwsti_tJon, analysisand design relatingto con,muction of theembenkn_ntfill and W_ bi_,hanioally S_iliz_! Earth 0riSE) Wall cI_a_s of _ laupos_! ThUd Runway F.xpandonProjectat the 8¢alfle Tacoma International Akport. C._oSyn_ f_t commJ_ed on proj,_t do_un_nts in a lett_' datcd*16 FebruaW 200I. This l©ttcrsummarizes O_Syntec's comments on documentsrelatingto th_projcctwhich were not availableduringthe tint r_vk_v. The. new d_um¢nts_evi¢_ _ t1_following: • '_co_hnicalEng_edngAnalysesandl_commeadatiora-ThirdRunway Embankment- SeaClc-T_.omsIn_'natIonal Airport- SeaTac, Washington," Preparedfor_ by HartCruwser,December4, 2000. • "AdditionalInformationon the Seismic I_dgn_" HartCrowserMmorandum, hauary25,2001. • "RcviscdMethodsandResultsof Liquef_tionAnalys_- ThirdRunway Embankment- SeaTac,Washing_ort,"HartCrowser_cmorandum,March5, 2001.... ,-- I:'_WK0)80_Submit||PC_oSyrltccSnT_ CornmclttLcucHl2,doc _t_, _t • Amen,I"X•/_..sIt_ Fb.ChkquoIL ._m_, GA,Atk=_0A.l_mh_s.MD• i.lual_,n_]Beck,CA•'_'_l_v__ CA ..... AR 021838 GsoSvme:C_ GeoSynteo'spersonnelin chargeof the reviewincludePa_ck C.Luole,Ph,D,, P.E,,andEdwardKavazaniian,Jr.,Ph.D.,P.E. Introduction L'xearlierlettersdated16 February2001, 15 March2001, and22 June2001, GeoSynte¢hasident_ed consistentgaps tnthe analysescarriedout by thePortof Seattleand its cormut_antsin their effom to design this project. The review of edditiona/documentspresentedhereinunfortunatelyfollowsthis trend. Aprojectof the , mai_tude and impodar_eof _e ThirdRunwayExpansi_ at lhe SeattleTacoma Intern_onalAirportrequiresa_erence to the highest of _de.,ds. The various elementsof r_edesignprocessmustbe scrutinizedst everylevel in orderto givethe resultings_tcture every chanceof weatheringextremeevenu;andremainingsafeand operationalfor the econnmlclifeofthe facilityandbeyond. In the discussionthatfollows, severalkey pointsandconcernswill be __ regarding_he analyses pz_sentedin these _:ently _'tewed clocuments. In our .discussions,we focuson thefollowingessentialfindings: • the seismic riskpresentedby thenumeroussourcesof potentialem_hquakesIn…
V V