EXH0193018498

PCHBPollution Control Hearings Board of the State of Washington

, Stockdale, Edk-- m|= i iii II _ ii i i i i From: Stor,kdale,Erik "'_ Sent: Thursday.July19,2001 10:32AM -:J To: 'JimKelley' ', Subject: RE:ThoughtsonLoraLake..... !t agreewithyourpremise.Thedifficultyhoweverisdetermininghowmuchcreditinacreagetoassigntotherestoration action.I think1to I iswaytoohigh,yet .25to I may beas easyto argueforas yourproposaltoreceive.5 to 1. Erik • _--Original Message.-.--- From:JimKelley[mailto:jckalleyOparametrix.com] Sent:.Thursday,July19,200110:07AM To: Stockdale,Erik Subject:ThoughtsonLoreLake..... " HighPriority"* Justsomethoughts..... Thequestionsyourabepointsa shortfall,inthisinstance,ofdeterminingmitigationcreditbasedonacreage.Theissueis somewhatanalogoustoremovalof a culvertthatis alsoa fishbarrier.Whilethemitigationactionoccursin a quitelimited area, thefunctionalbenefitran occursovera broaderarea. Regardlessof area,itseemsimportanttorecognizethe functionalvalueof themitigationtothelake. ThesewouldInclude Increasedshade,increasedlitterandterrestrialinsectinputtothelake(benefittingr_,handaquaticlife),andnew •;._J amphibianbreedingsites(fromsmallbranchesfallingintothe lake). The removalof yardmaintenancecouldalsobenefit waterquality.Thesefunctionalbenefitscancompensateforsomeof thepotentialfunctionalimpactswe areconcerned abouL JimKelley jcke_parametrix.com Paramebix,I_, Main: 425-822-8880FAX:425-889-8808 Direct:425-828-4202extn3315 AR 018499 l)(|r 7?Jtml tlt)t|._ EXH0193018498 EXH0193018499
V V